GDG- Inevitable defeat

joadx1 at joadx1 at
Tue Jan 24 11:19:26 CST 2012

 It would appear, then, that Lee was quite willing to ignore the Napoleonic maxims.  At Chancellorsville, for example, he divided his army.  Jackson's flanking maneuver was not overwhelming force; it was successful surprise that succeeded because Lee anticipated Hooker's reaction.  Second Manassas was a successful ambush of an army that didn't know where Longstreet was.  Pickett's Charge was hardly overwhelming force.

In short, Lee made do with the human resources he had, which were never overwhelming in numbers.  He relied on speed and surprise, and on the morale of his forces.  He also relied on his knowledge of the AoP commanders.  A lot of psychology was involved, but rarely, if ever,  overwhelming force.



-----Original Message-----
From: CWMHTours <CWMHTours at>
To: gettysburg <gettysburg at>
Sent: Tue, Jan 24, 2012 9:08 am
Subject: Re: GDG- Inevitable defeat

Esteemed GDG Member Contributes:
When you consider Lee as a general it is helpful, if not  required, to 
remember the 2 Napoleonic Maxims of Warfare, which  are:
1.  Always strike with overwhelming  force.....
If you remember those 2 maxims you can start to  get a  handle on  R.E. Lee.
He was a master of those.
ie. Witness Chancellorville or 2 nd Man.  The man was  briilliant.  If you 
were in his shoes it would be hard to deviate from his  actions, unless you 
are a dumb guy,  which fortunately we are  not.
Pemberton and J Johnston had some 50k men between  them. With a 1000 miles 
between them and Lee he did the right  thing.
The fortress of Washington was  his focus.  He  needed as mny people as 
possible.  Because it was a fortress he knew that  he could never successfully 
attack it.  He had to get the Northern forces  away from DC in order to 
bring overwhelming force on the  AoP.
If you go into Penn you keep the Yanks off balance.  And  if you can, you 
attack with overwhelming force.
It's actually very simple to understand Lee in that  light.
Do you like my new sign-off?  I don't know what a  neo-anti unionst is but 
I like how it sounds.
A  Loyal Neo-Anti Unionist,



More information about the Gettysburg mailing list